Skip to main content

Medical Advice as Theater of the Absurd

By now, it should be clear that doctors' admonitions to lose weight and exercise more have little impact on our long-term, day-to-day behavior.  We all know this already from sad personal experience.  But we also know it from many studies, and from the multi-decade worsening in Americans' obesity and other chronic conditions.  The medical profession has been begging us for countless years to improve our health behavior--to almost no avail.

Yet the fantastical headlines persist, even in publications like the Washington Post: 

"Losing 13 percent of your weight could lead to big improvements in your health"  

It is hard enough for adults to lose even 5 pounds and to keep it off--much less the 15-30+ pounds implied by "13%".  It is very rare to pull off sustained weight loss of this magnitude.  

In fact, the only proven way currently to achieve this much permanent weight loss, on a whole-population scale, is the last resort, when all else has failed--bariatric surgery.  Permanently re-engineering a morbidly obese person's gastrointestinal system--with resulting lifelong nutrient deficiencies & numerous other potentially serious side effects.

We continue to stand by, while obese children become severely obese teens (>75 lbs. overweight) and then morbidly obese (>100 lbs. overweight) adults.  We are heading rapidly toward 24% of all adults being severely obese by 2030--"with high predictive accuracy", according to the well-respected New England Journal of Medicine.  

So as MDs' admonitions to lose a lot of weight continue to fail, are we going to perform bariatric surgery on 10-20% of all adults?!  (This assumes people will even agree to the surgery, even though only 1% of those eligible choose bariatric surgery currently.)

That last-resort prospect is deeply disturbing, as well as unethical--given that we have never even implemented the "first resort".  Unless we do much more to develop healthy habits in children, which can only realistically be done in K-12 settings, we are destining an increasing percentage of Americans to an unhealthy life. 





Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Citizen-ready civics: the powerful synergy of knowledge plus engagement

Boy, am I an infrequent blogger!  I do want to assure you, though, that I am alive and working on our focus areas.  In particular, there is a window of opportunity opening in the "life-ready" area in Arizona.   The Arizona Department of Health Services has recently determined, after a comprehensive statewide review process, that obesity is the number one health issue facing Arizona.  Other preventable chronic conditions such as heart disease and diabetes were also identified as major AZ health issues. Furthermore, we already know that four of the five root causes of the vast majority of these conditions are unhealthy nutrition, lack of physical activity, smoking, and excess drinking.  (Genetics plays a role as well, but healthy behavior can often trump genetics.)   At the same time, a number of organizations and individuals are frustrated by the increasing narrowing of our public K-12 education, and the dire consequences of downplaying social studies and health educ
Post a Comment
Read more

Urban food myth #1: it costs more to eat healthy than to eat fast food

I get so tired of hearing this: "It costs less to buy a burger from McDonald's that to eat healthy food from the supermarket." "Low-income families just buy processed food, they don't cook their own food anymore." That always sounded questionable.  Here is a study showing in great detail that fast food is much more expensive than healthy food bought at the supermarket . Also, it turns out that the vast majority of meals eaten by low-income families are prepared at home: Blisard N, Stewart H. How low-income households allocate their food budget relative to the cost of the Thrifty Food Plan. Economic research report, United States. Washington, DC: Department of Agriculture, Economic Research Service, 2006;20. What is true is that buying healthy vs. unhealthy foods can cost $1.50/person/day more, at retail prices.  However, when health cost consequences are factored in, unhealthy foods cost twice as much .
2 comments
Read more

Health "benefits"?: Oh well...

We meet them all the time:  people trapped in their job, in order to keep their health benefits.   We need a study on the negative impact on entrepreneurship and the economy from people health-handcuffed to their current jobs.  From my limited anecdoctal evidence, the costs are astronomical.   Two-income families have made the labor market much more geographically immobile, and now health insurance is exacerbating the job-jail. Modern Healthcare just summarized results of a new Peterson-Kaiser study  on employer health insurance and the actual cost to employee families, of the combination of employee share of premiums plus employee out-of-pocket health costs. Employers keep shifting more and more health costs to employees. The only good news is that employers are still paying a (fast-shrinking) % of premiums--so health costs are still cheaper than being self-employed.  [Also, if we end up back in the uncovered pre-existing conditions bad-old-days again, expensive employer heal
1 comment
Read more