Skip to main content

To Re-Open Or Not To Re-open Schools?--That is the Question!

My take so far on school reopenings based on very preliminary data: 

- The countries with the best school reopening track records have typically had quite restricted formats such as very small, highly distanced class sizes plus low country COVID-19 case levels per capita--many less infections per person than in the USA.  So we need to realize that we can't just copy what they did.

- The biggest risk seems to be to teachers & staff.  Kids are less vulnerable & less infectious.  We need to consider all of them, and parents, too!

- If we can flatten the state curve & have hospital capacity, it seems worth letting schools without local spikes reopen very carefully physically--including with recess! 

- Then track closely & share immediately what is happening & learn from each other.

- Let's get real:  Given the shortcomings of our hastily improvised hybrid teaching models, by this time next year, we could easily have lost on average 1/2 year or more of learning, particularly among lower-income students.  Yet we will have less tax revenue to pay for recovery-learning, due to the economic downturn & family budgets.

- So a big part of the risk to kids that we need to consider is their overall K-12 educational & health attainment, which will determine much of their lifelong socioeconomic well-being.  We can't just focus on what they are risking right now.

- The coronavirus pandemic is much more deadly due to the 40+ year pre-existing epidemic of chronic disease:  heart disease, obesity, diabetes, etc.  Younger adults with severe obesity, which typically started as child inactivity & obesity, seem to be at particularly high risk for their age from COVID-19. 

- The chronic disease epidemic is being caused more than anything else by inactivity & unhealthy nutrition.  Yet the viral pandemic is reducing activity & healthy nutrition further for children, by decreasing recess, PE, health ed, school meals, etc.--not to mention the stress & social-emotional impact.  The pandemic is accelerating a pre-existing downward spiral.

- It's time to start considering both short- and long-term how we should proceed in the coming months!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Is it a “Miracle Drug”?...if it Costs a Fortune and Creates Lifelong Dependency...&...Saggy Faces!?

[It’s been a while since our last blog post.  A lot has happened since– including some “miracles” ! So we’re going to do two posts in a row…] Normally we should all be happy about miracle drugs... shouldn't we ? Yes, there is lots of upside from taking semaglutide (Ozempic, Wegovy), tirzepatide (Montjaro)--and upcoming new, even-more-miraculous drugs TBD:  losing huge amounts of weight quickly, a much lower risk of diabetes–and probably less heart disease and other chronic conditions as well.  But what if the “miracle” requires:   $200-300/week, with a lifetime cost of hundreds of thousands of dollars…  a drug that you can never quit…because if you stop taking it, you gain back all the weight it helped you lose–not to mention the chronic diseases which the drugs kept at bay… and it leaves your face (and the rest of your skin?) sagging …    (plus, it’s so new at such high dosages– who knows what happens after years of use…? ) No doubt, in spit...

It’s Come To This for Many of Our Teens: Radical Surgery and/or a Lifetime of Pharmaceuticals

The American Academy of Pediatrics just came out in favor of powerful prescription drugs (which must be taken lifelong to avoid weight regain & chronic disease) for adolescents--and potentially for pre-teens (ages 8-11)--with moderate to severe obesity. Bari atric surgery (permanently reengineering kids’ gastrointestinal systems) should also be considered for adolescents with severe obesity .  (The Academy also recommends "nutrition support, physical activity, and behavioral therapy"--but as with so many other areas of US chronic disease management, we can see where default treatments are headed: drugs & surgical procedures.) Such radical treatment recommendations created the usual (and temporary and ineffectual) tsunami of news & social media shock and indignation. The decades-long performative reaction to the increasingly bad news on dangerous levels of early obesity–and now 1 in 3 teens with prediabetes, across ethnicities & income levels–is itself sicken...

Both/And: Personal & School & Social Responsibility for Health

Many people are promoting a false dichotomy for who/what to “blame” for decades of pervasive inactivity & unhealthy nutrition--the key preventable factors which have led to the majority of adults developing chronic disease. Some believe that people with preventable chronic diseases made a series of unhealthy choices for decades, for which they need to accept personal responsibility for the consequences. On the other side, a growing number of policymakers focus on the “social determinants of health.”  In other words, there are many things beyond your control, which impact what you eat & drink and how active you are.  This includes factors such as your family, neighborhood, school, employer, transportation, public safety, housing, community layout, etc. etc.  It’s those external social factors which determine your health destiny.   Actually, the personal and social are inextricably connected--not opposite ends of the spectrum.  Let’s consider the role...